Glenn & Reeta have developed an affinity for True Crime Documentaries during their time at 105.7 The Fan and spend every show reviewing what we watched that week in a segment we like to call “Book Club.” We’ve enlisted the help of Ken Weinman and Tim Barbalace from the The Fan as well, with a few guest appearances from our producers and other co-hosts from time-to-time…
Here’s a complete catalog of what we’ve reviewed so far (all rating on a scale of 1-10):
This week, we watched the Season 6 debut of Netflix’s “Untold” series, “The Death & Life Of Lamar Odom.” There was a bit too much Richard Hunter and they tried to clean things up a bit more nicely than things appear BUT it was really interesting and compelling and about a billion times better than the completely unwatchable and garbage “Untold” about Florida football. Watch this week’s show here.
April 6, 2026 – Untold: The Death & Life of Lamar Odom
Glenn 7.25/10
Reeta 7.75/10
Caleb 8/10
Mystery Rater 7.5/10
March 30, 2026 – Dirty Rotten Scandals: The Price Is Right
Glenn 3/10
Reeta 5.5/10
Caleb 5/10
March 23, 2026 – Crack: Cocaine, Corruption & Conspiracy
Glenn 7.75/10
Reeta 8/10
Caleb 7.5/10
March 19, 2026 – The Investigation Of Lucy Letby
Glenn 4/10
Reeta 4.5/10
Caleb 5.5/10
March 10, 2026 – Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story
Glenn 6.25/10
Reeta 7.5/10
Caleb 7/10
February 19, 2026 – Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model
Glenn 5.25/10
Reeta 6/10
Caleb 5.5/10
February 12, 2026 – Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart
Glenn – 7.9/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 7.95/10
January 15, 2026 – Murder in Monaco
Glenn – 8.5/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 7/10
December 23, 2025 – Predators
Glenn – 5.75/10
Reeta – 4/10
Caleb – 9/10
December 10, 2025 – Girl In The Picture
Glenn – 8.5/10
Reeta – 8.75/10
Griffin – 8/10
November 25, 2025 – The Carman Family Deaths
Glenn – 7/10
Reeta – 7.5/10
Caleb – 9/10
November 18, 2025 – Caroline Flack: Search For The Truth
Glenn – 3.5/10
Reeta – 3/10
Caleb – 6.5/10
November 5, 2025 – Who Killed The Montréal Expos?
Glenn – 8/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 8/10
October 23, 2025 – The Perfect Neighbor
Glenn – 9/10
Reeta – 8.5/10
Caleb – 9/10
October 16, 2025 – Death In Apartment 603
Glenn – 4/10
Reeta – 4/10
Griffin – 5/10
September 29, 2025 – Cocaine Quarterback
Glenn – 8.75/10
Reeta – 8.5/10
Caleb – 8.5/10
September 15, 2025 – Unknown Number
Glenn – 7/10
Reeta – 7/10
Caleb – 8.5/10
August 27, 2025 – Fit For TV: The Reality of The Biggest Loser
Glenn – 8
Reeta – 8
Caleb – 7.75
August 7, 2025 – A Deadly American Marriage
Glenn – 8.25
Reeta – 9
Caleb – 8
July 24, 2025 – Amy Bradley Is Missing
Glenn – 8.75
Reeta – 5
Caleb – 8
July 15, 2025 – Long Shot
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 9
Caleb – 9.5
July 3, 2025 – Trainwreck: Poop Cruise
Glenn – 7.5
Reeta – 7
Caleb – 5
Cordell Woodland – 8
June 18, 2025 – Titan: The OceanGate Disaster
Glenn – 6.5
Reeta – 6
Griffin – 7
June 11, 2025 – Orgasm Inc: The Story of OneTaste
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 7
Caleb – 8
April 1, 2025 – Belle Gibson: The Search for Instagram’s Worst Con Artist
Glenn – 4
Reeta – 2
Tim – 6.2
Ken- 7.3
March 25, 2025 – Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare
Glenn – 3.5
Reeta – 5.5
Tim – 6.5
Ken – 7.8
March 11, 2025 – American Murder: Gabby Petito
Glenn – 7.2
Reeta – 8.5
Tim – 7.8
Ken – 7.5
March 5, 2025 – Scamanda
Glenn – 6.8
Reeta – 7.5
Tim – 7.1
Ken – 6.9
February 4, 2025 – Jerry Springer: Fights, Camera, Action
Glenn – 5.8
Reeta – 4
Tim – 7.4
Ken – 3.2
January 28, 2025 – The Kings of Tupelo: A Southern Crime Saga
Glenn – 9.7
Reeta – 9.5
Tim – 8.7
Ken – 9.1
January 21, 2025 – ChiefsAholic: A Wolf in Chiefs Clothing
Glenn – 7
Reeta – 6.5
Tim – 7.2
Ken – 6.9
January 9, 2025 – Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 8
Tim – 8.4
Ken – 8.2
November 24, 2024 – The Menedez Brothers
Glenn – 7
Reeta – 8
Tim – 8.1
Ken – 7.8
November 13, 2024 – Anatomy of Lies
Glenn – 8.2
Reeta – 8.5
Tim – 8.7
Ken – 9
