Glenn & Reeta have developed an affinity for True Crime Documentaries during their time at 105.7 The Fan and spend every show reviewing what we watched that week in a segment we like to call “Book Club.” We’ve enlisted the help of Ken Weinman and Tim Barbalace from the The Fan as well, with a few guest appearances from our producers and other co-hosts from time-to-time…
Here’s a complete catalog of what we’ve reviewed so far (all rating on a scale of 1-10):
This week, we watched the new Netflix documentary “The Investigation Of Lucy Letby” about the series of infant deaths that were apparently perpetrated by a British nurse. It is confusing, it is generally difficult to watch and it leaves with you with many questions. We didn’t really like this one. Watch this week’s show here.
March 19, 2026 – The Investigation Of Lucy Letby
Glenn 4/10
Reeta 4.5/10
Caleb 5.5/10
March 10, 2026 – Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story
Glenn 6.25/10
Reeta 7.5/10
Caleb 7/10
February 19, 2026 – Reality Check: Inside America’s Next Top Model
Glenn 5.25/10
Reeta 6/10
Caleb 5.5/10
February 12, 2026 – Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart
Glenn – 7.9/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 7.95/10
January 15, 2026 – Murder in Monaco
Glenn – 8.5/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 7/10
December 23, 2025 – Predators
Glenn – 5.75/10
Reeta – 4/10
Caleb – 9/10
December 10, 2025 – Girl In The Picture
Glenn – 8.5/10
Reeta – 8.75/10
Griffin – 8/10
November 25, 2025 – The Carman Family Deaths
Glenn – 7/10
Reeta – 7.5/10
Caleb – 9/10
November 18, 2025 – Caroline Flack: Search For The Truth
Glenn – 3.5/10
Reeta – 3/10
Caleb – 6.5/10
November 5, 2025 – Who Killed The Montréal Expos?
Glenn – 8/10
Reeta – 8/10
Caleb – 8/10
October 23, 2025 – The Perfect Neighbor
Glenn – 9/10
Reeta – 8.5/10
Caleb – 9/10
October 16, 2025 – Death In Apartment 603
Glenn – 4/10
Reeta – 4/10
Griffin – 5/10
September 29, 2025 – Cocaine Quarterback
Glenn – 8.75/10
Reeta – 8.5/10
Caleb – 8.5/10
September 15, 2025 – Unknown Number
Glenn – 7/10
Reeta – 7/10
Caleb – 8.5/10
August 27, 2025 – Fit For TV: The Reality of The Biggest Loser
Glenn – 8
Reeta – 8
Caleb – 7.75
August 7, 2025 – A Deadly American Marriage
Glenn – 8.25
Reeta – 9
Caleb – 8
July 24, 2025 – Amy Bradley Is Missing
Glenn – 8.75
Reeta – 5
Caleb – 8
July 15, 2025 – Long Shot
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 9
Caleb – 9.5
July 3, 2025 – Trainwreck: Poop Cruise
Glenn – 7.5
Reeta – 7
Caleb – 5
Cordell Woodland – 8
June 18, 2025 – Titan: The OceanGate Disaster
Glenn – 6.5
Reeta – 6
Griffin – 7
June 11, 2025 – Orgasm Inc: The Story of OneTaste
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 7
Caleb – 8
April 1, 2025 – Belle Gibson: The Search for Instagram’s Worst Con Artist
Glenn – 4
Reeta – 2
Tim – 6.2
Ken- 7.3
March 25, 2025 – Sweet Bobby: My Catfish Nightmare
Glenn – 3.5
Reeta – 5.5
Tim – 6.5
Ken – 7.8
March 11, 2025 – American Murder: Gabby Petito
Glenn – 7.2
Reeta – 8.5
Tim – 7.8
Ken – 7.5
March 5, 2025 – Scamanda
Glenn – 6.8
Reeta – 7.5
Tim – 7.1
Ken – 6.9
February 4, 2025 – Jerry Springer: Fights, Camera, Action
Glenn – 5.8
Reeta – 4
Tim – 7.4
Ken – 3.2
January 28, 2025 – The Kings of Tupelo: A Southern Crime Saga
Glenn – 9.7
Reeta – 9.5
Tim – 8.7
Ken – 9.1
January 21, 2025 – ChiefsAholic: A Wolf in Chiefs Clothing
Glenn – 7
Reeta – 6.5
Tim – 7.2
Ken – 6.9
January 9, 2025 – Into the Fire: The Lost Daughter
Glenn – 8.5
Reeta – 8
Tim – 8.4
Ken – 8.2
November 24, 2024 – The Menedez Brothers
Glenn – 7
Reeta – 8
Tim – 8.1
Ken – 7.8
November 13, 2024 – Anatomy of Lies
Glenn – 8.2
Reeta – 8.5
Tim – 8.7
Ken – 9
